The movie also features scenes from the perspective of Mr. Darcy, these are additional and not in the book. This was done to show Darcy as more human as well as to show the genuine closeness of his friendship with the character of Mr. The movie was well-received by critics, with Keira Knightley being nominated for an Academy Award for Best Actress and was a success at the box office.
Austen fans and British viewers of the film had divided opinions. The movie has other differences than just the dialogue. In the movie, Elizabeth keeps secrets from her family and grows apart from her older sister Jane. This is different from the book, while Elizabeth does become frustrated with events related to her family, she never keeps secrets from them. She also confides in her sister after difficult events, they never grow apart.
The movie also portrays Mr. Bennett as a warmer, more sympathetic father than he is in the book. His role in the family misfortunes, caused by him spending money on the wrong things, is downplayed.
His relationship with his wife is much more loving in the movie. However, the movie also makes the Bennetts look poorer than they were in the book.
Collins, the miniseries makes no such display: Charlotte's choice of mate was a cold, pragmatic decision based solely on financial prospects, and in later scenes with Elizabeth, we see her realize the full consequences of marrying an idiot with means, both good and bad. The BBC's miniseries is the rare instance in which the screen adaptation of a novel serves as an equally worthy companion piece to the written source material, and both works are strong and delightful in their own right.
Watching the cast verbally spar with each other using Austen's savagely witty words offers an incredible showcase of the author's gift for language and satire.
Her dialogue drips with cutting humor, all the funnier and more devastating for being couched in courtly niceties. While the film carefully spells things out for the audience, the miniseries relies on subtlety, and to great effect; it's astonishing how much Ehle's Lizzie can communicate with a suppressed smile or a peevishly arched brow. Here, again, the film fails to measure up — a fact perhaps best exemplified by the character of Mr.
In the film, a grizzled Donald Sutherland plays the character as benevolent and world-weary; he mumbles his lines, blunting Austen's sharp dialogue with his mellowness until he nearly disappears into the scenery at times check out his slouched posture here :. But in the hands of the miniseries' Mr.
Bennet, Benjamin Whitrow, the dialogue comes alive. Suddenly the long-suffering patriarch's exchanges crackle with a wicked sense of humor; he delights in teasing his wife and is always ready to share a joke with his favorite daughter at anyone's expense. Bennet's special bond with Lizzie far more vivid, while also explaining how an intelligent man could end up with a drama queen like Mrs.
Bennet — and how his love of the ridiculous could cause him to occasionally delve into "impropriety" himself, as Darcy memorably chides Elizabeth. It's through words, after all, that Austen brought her world and characters alive; and, fittingly, it's in staying true to those words that the BBC's take on Pride and Prejudice manages to outstrip all the rest. Correction: This post originally misidentified the actor who played Mr.
Wickham in 's Pride and Prejudice. Our mission has never been more vital than it is in this moment: to empower through understanding. Financial contributions from our readers are a critical part of supporting our resource-intensive work and help us keep our journalism free for all. Please consider making a contribution to Vox today to help us keep our work free for all.
Cookie banner We use cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your browsing experience on our site, show personalized content and targeted ads, analyze site traffic, and understand where our audiences come from.
By choosing I Accept , you consent to our use of cookies and other tracking technologies. Reddit Pocket Flipboard Email. BBC Thanksgiving weekend is a time to eat too much and argue with your family, and if you've already worked your way through such controversial topics as vaccinations and Black Lives Matter , here's another one to add to the list: The BBC's Pride and Prejudice is hands down the best adaptation of the Jane Austen novel ever made.
The key romantic pairs are so much more charming and believable Pride and Prejudice requires a suitably dreamy Mr. Darcy emerging, dripping wet, from a lake — only to encounter a shocked Elizabeth Bennet: Meanwhile, the film reduced the story's epic romance to mush. Consider this moment when, after brutally rebuffing Darcy's proposal, Elizabeth inexplicably looks like she's about to make out with him: But it's not just Elizabeth and Darcy — the film's Jane and Mr.
The supporting cast is equally stellar I say this knowing that the film is stuffed with stars — Rosamund Pike, Jena Malone, Carey Mulligan — and well-known character actors, while the BBC cast a bunch of Brits who were and remain largely unknown to American audiences. It explores the full scope of the Bennet women's limited world The miniseries' nearly six-hour runtime does more than just allow it to devote more space to minor plots and characters — it also leaves far more room for world building, fully sketching in the limited contours of the women's world.
It does full justice to Jane Austen's razor-sharp dialogue The BBC's miniseries is the rare instance in which the screen adaptation of a novel serves as an equally worthy companion piece to the written source material, and both works are strong and delightful in their own right.
I love lots of films of this era, but my feelings about this adaptation are similar to my feelings about the film. As an adaptation, it falls short of in that it makes too many changes to the plot, and it attempts period costume and gets it wrong.
The lead actors, especially those playing Elizabeth and Jane, are charming, and the script makes some clever tweaks to the story. Pride and Prejudice and Zombies The biggest trouble is that this Darcy has the charisma of a wet dishcloth. This television miniseries suffers from being almost too faithful. I had my copy of the book nearby as I watched, and it is almost a scene-by-scene adaptation.
However, I felt that it was faithful to the letter and not to the spirit of the novel. The performances are competent but flat, especially among the lead characters. Lost in Austen I know many, many people who are fans of this miniseries in which a modern-day Jane Austen fan ends up in the world of Pride and Prejudice.
0コメント